← Club de Debates

3

Add a “Reproduce Existing Bug” Feature with Device-Wise Verification and Tester Rewards

Yashoda Yashoda · hace 1 día · 47 visitas
1. Problem Observed

Sometimes a bug occurs only on a particular device or Android version. For example, I experienced loading screen freezing issues in both Underground Fight and Sea Stirs on my Oppo A15s running Android 10.

However, other testers may not experience the same issue on their devices. When a similar bug report already exists, another tester may hesitate to submit it because it could be marked as a duplicate.

Currently, it would be helpful to have a way for other testers to check an existing bug on their own devices and share their results directly under the original report.

2. Proposed Solution

I suggest adding a “Reproduce Existing Bug” option to bug reports.

This feature would allow other testers to open an existing bug report, follow the provided steps, and check whether the same issue occurs on their devices.

After testing, they could select one of these results:

Reproduced: The same bug also occurs on their device.

Not Reproduced: The bug does not occur on their device.

Partially Reproduced: The issue occurs, but not exactly as described.

The system could automatically include the tester's device model, Android version, and other relevant environment details.

Testers could also attach screenshots or screen recordings as evidence. All reproduction results would appear under the original bug report instead of creating separate duplicate reports.

3. Suggested Payment and Reward System

I would also like to suggest introducing a reward system for testers who help reproduce and verify existing bugs.

For example:

Testers who successfully reproduce an existing bug could receive a verification reward.

Testers who provide useful screenshots or screen recordings could receive additional rewards, depending on the quality of their evidence.

Testers who cannot reproduce the issue could still receive consideration for their verification effort.

Reproduction results from different devices and Android versions could be especially valuable for identifying device-specific problems.

Could you please clarify whether testers would receive payment for reproducing or verifying existing bugs? If this feature is introduced, it would be helpful to have clear reward amounts and eligibility rules.

4. Benefits

This feature could help QAProvider and project owners in several ways:

Reduce duplicate bug reports.

Identify device-specific and Android-version-specific issues.

Collect verification results from multiple testers.

Understand how many devices are affected by the same bug.

Give developers more reliable information for fixing issues.

Make it easier to verify whether a reported bug has been fixed.

Give testers another way to contribute and earn rewards.

5. Testing and Observations

I have personally experienced loading screen freezing issues in Underground Fight and Sea Stirs on my Oppo A15s (Android 10).

These experiences made me think that a bug reproduction feature could help confirm whether similar issues also occur on other devices.

I believe this feature would make bug verification more useful for testers, project owners, and developers.

 Thank you for considering this suggestion.

1 comentarios

0
QAProvider QAProvider · hace 1 día

Yashoda, thank you for such a detailed suggestion!

We understand the problem well: a bug that shows up only on one device or Android version is easy to lose, and testers hesitate to report something that may be marked as a duplicate. Your idea of confirming an existing bug on other devices and keeping all the results under the original report is interesting, and we have taken it for consideration.

We cannot promise payment or exact amounts yet. If rewards for verification are introduced, we need to design the rules carefully so that they cannot be abused. We will think about how to organize this and will come back to the discussion if we decide to build it.

Thanks again for helping make QAProvider better.
QAProvider team

Iniciar sesión para unirte a la conversación.